“Why Is No One Replying to My Stories?!” Here’s Why…

I know the feeling… you’re posting your heart out on Stories, sharing behind-the-scenes moments, cute coffee shots, and even the occasional offer… but your DMs? Crickets.

It’s not because people aren’t watching (they are!), it’s because your stories aren’t giving them a reason to respond.

There are six types of story content I swear by and mixing them in is the secret sauce to boosting your engagement (and eventually, sales). Here's what to add ASAP:

• Conversation Starters – Ask a question. Share a spicy take. Invite your audience to chime in.

• “Omg, Me Too” Moments – Relatable content is engagement gold. Make them laugh or nod along.

• Palette Cleansers – Aesthetic images or chill BRB slides keep things flowing without being overwhelming.

• Selling Points – Casual reminders of what you do + how people can work with you.

• Interactive Tools – Polls, sliders, quizzes — Instagram gives us the tools, let’s use them!

• Quick Value – Share helpful tips, fav apps, or book recs. Little things that make people say, “That was actually helpful.”

Remember: If your Stories feel like they’re flopping, it’s not you—it’s the content mix. Time to shift it and start building real connections.